Former WKU Coach Bill Powell Responds to Program Suspension

fabian-schwingenschlogl-western-kentucky-ncaa-2015 (2)
Photo Courtesy: Andy Ringgold

Former Western Kentucky head swimming coach Bill Powell is not happy with the news that his former WKU swimming and diving program has been suspended for five years after accusations of severe hazing.

Powell retired in 2005 after 36 years at the helm of the Hilltoppers program.  During that time period, his teams won 15 conference titles and the Natatorium at WKU is named after him.

Here is his response in full:

Dear WKU Swimmers, Divers, Friends, and Supporters,

I am devastated at the loss of WKU Swimming and Diving—an athletic program that has graduated virtually all of its team members over a 45-year period. As Dr. Ransdell himself admits, the team has collected too many academic honors to list and its student-athletes have “represented WKU with distinction in the classroom and in competition.” I am certainly proud of what you all have accomplished.

I have been retired from the WKU swim program for a while, so my knowledge of the alleged incidents is no more than what everyone else has seen in the papers. It appears that the transgressions were perpetrated primarily by one or two team members, and no criminal charges have been filed.

As a teacher I was never one for disciplining a whole class for the actions of one or two students. Nor would I discipline an entire team for the actions of one or two athletes. In this case more than 50 innocent, hardworking students are receiving a devastating punishment for something for which they are not responsible. In addition, five coaches are unemployed because of the actions of a very few others.

WKU will lose most, if not all, of these fine students—and the university will also lose a winning tradition, made stellar by the actions of 99% of its student-athletes.

Finally, the city of Bowling Green will lose the WKU Swimming and Diving fundraising one-on-one swim lessons, which have taught thousands of B.G. children to swim over the years.

I know that the University was facing a difficult situation and some form of punitive action was necessary. However, this excessive penalty unfairly punishes many current athletes and all prospective athletes. I believe a better course would be to discipline or terminate the staff and athletes who were directly involved, or those who had the responsibility to intervene and failed to do so.

WKU Swimming has always represented more to me than just my job, and I look on each of you alums as members of my giant extended family. I thank the hundreds of alumni, friends, and supporters who have called, written, e-mailed, sent gifts, and expressed their appreciation for this fine program over the years and this week. You can best represent the legacy of this program by continuing to do as you did while you were on the Hill: be better than most at everything you do.

Coach

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

Welcome to our community. We invite you to join our discussion. Our community guidelines are simple: be respectful and constructive, keep on topic, and support your fellow commenters. Commenting signifies that you agree to our Terms of Use

35 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Sally43
Sally43
9 years ago

I think it is funny that he does not address any of the problems that have been stated. No mention of the girl being sexually assaulted or of the racial words/language. All I hear is, “well we won a bunch of swim meets for the past 30 years and so we should be able to do what we want. 5 years? Thats b.s.” It was not just 1 or 2 people Mr. Powell. You are disgusting.

Swimmer
Swimmer
9 years ago
Reply to  Sally43

You have no idea what you are talking about. Nor any clue about the man you insult from behind your computer screen.

Tre
Tre
9 years ago
Reply to  Swimmer

Shocking, a swimmer saying nothing happened.

WKU Alum
WKU Alum
9 years ago
Reply to  Swimmer

Sally, you seem to have missed the part about Powell being the former coach. He started the program but has not coached there for years. These comments are to his alums.

Secondly, nowhere does Powell mention winning any meets or using his won-lost record as justification. Those comments came from Swimming World by way of introduction. Powell does mention a near 100% graduation rate over 45 years and “too many academic awards to list” per the university President.

Finally, the full police complaint is available on Twitter. The “girl being sexually assaulted” had no idea what the university administrator that contacted her was talking about. She thought it must have been another girl so the second girl was also contacted by the university. That young woman also said that she had not been sexually assaulted. As for the racial slurs, well if you think cutting an entire men’s and women’s program is justifiable punishment, I think most people will disagree.

Bill
Bill
9 years ago
Reply to  Swimmer

I think you missed the part where he does mention winning: “WKU will lose most, if not all, of these fine students—and the university will also lose a winning tradition, made stellar by the actions of 99% of its student-athletes.”

Also, if you read the report then you know that it was not just 1 or 2 people, you will know that the victim gives dates and times for everything, you will know that the swim team (at least 5 of them that lived there) had nude photos of other people where they were clearly intoxicated to the point of not knowing what was happening. Just because criminal charges havent been filed yet doesnt mean they arent coming. This incident was reported at the beginning of this year and it is just not having the consequences.

SwimMom
SwimMom
9 years ago
Reply to  Sally43

I agree with you, Sally. Everybody is treating these actions as if they were “no big deal”. They are! These privileged college kids know right from wrong and know that there are consequences to criminal behavior. With it becoming increasingly difficult to afford higher education, these scholarship athletes should be more respectful of what they’ve been given and not treat college as a four year frat party. Coach Powell states that those responsible for the actions AND those responsible responsible for intervening should be punished. The ENTIRE TEAM including its coaches was responsible for intervening. I don’t believe for a second that there was anyone on that team that didn’t know what was going on. The punishment, in my opinion, is indeed devastating, but merited nonetheless.

AvantSwim
AvantSwim
9 years ago
Reply to  Sally43

While a 5-year suspension seems severe–I agree–there can be little doubt of the disgusting, pervasive culture of bullying, harassment (sexual and otherwise), violence, intimidation and illegal activity that was both permitted and promoted by the coaching staff, team captains and upper classmen. It was certainly more than “one or two bad apples” and any such trivializing or minimizing sentiments should be met with the scorn they deserve.

There is apparently concrete evidence that the head coach knew of this type of activity since 2012: I would penalize the team for three years–dating from that moment, and demand the University repay all aquatics-related public funds during that time. The coach should be charged for criminal conspiracy and as a participating accomplice to all relevant crimes. He should be fired immediately, not in June. Three years would allow a time of penalty, as well as time for the program to clean house and rebuild.

For the posters, and ex-coach who ask “why should everyone be penalized?”–that is a fair sentiment. But remember, this too is no-one’s fault except for the coaches, captains, and administrators and swimmers who engaged in these crimes, looked the other way or failed to intervene. This is far too large a group to blame on a few select people, and I doubt the public sentiment would quelled with a few scapegoats. This particular program clearly had an endemic, systematic and malignant sickness that has infected the whole team. Unfortunately, this program needs to be gutted to be investigated thoroughly and rebuilt with careful consideration and contrition.

Swimmer2
Swimmer2
9 years ago
Reply to  Sally43

Clearly , Sally 43,swimmom, and all the other opinionated haters seem to think their account of what actually happened and who knew about it should reign supreme above those much closer to the situation than they were.First, sally43, if you knew the man you call “disgusting” then you would realize what a judgmental fool you really are. He has the respect and admiration of not only the swimming community ,but the entire school !! Secondly, you falsely accuse MANY with your statement that everyone knew of these incidents. I had 2 swimmers on this team and neither had any idea of these kind of incidents. They are fortunate that they won’t be effected by the acts of a few. And to the idiot that believes they all have scholarships and are privileged kids that should know better..i would suggest you get your facts straight before you make comments that are actually false. To punish so many was wrong. Investigate and punish the perpetrators.. It will become evident that this is a very sad day for WKU . .And for those that will pay the price for the bad actions of others..my heart goes out to you.

SwimFan
SwimFan
9 years ago
Reply to  Sally43

Please re-read. Coach Powell doesn’t *know* the details, not having been coach for 10 years. How could he address the problems? Some people don’t comment on things they don’t know anything about.

I would think most swim parents would prefer their children not lose their ENTIRE TEAM because some of their teammates are doing the wrong thing, and I doubt those kids would be too happy about it–and are they really responsible for what those kids are doing? What would your kids have done? NO ONE is saying it’s “no big deal” what the perpetrators did.

Phil
Phil
9 years ago

There have been no arrests, no charges, only the accusations of one disgruntled freshman. And what appears to be a couple of seniors that were bullies. Fire the coaches for taking no action & expell the bullies. But why punish 50 innocent athletes for this?

Anyone who would bash Coach Powell has never met the man.

Guest
Guest
9 years ago
Reply to  Phil

It can’t be overstated. When hazing occurs, the team is aware. By not saying anything and looking the other way, they become part of the problem. It is no different than the coaches. In fact, I would argue it is worse because they are witness to the hazing and experienced it themselves.

calitricrys
calitricrys
9 years ago

You know what they say about opinions folks. Of course there should be consequences to the actions of those involved, without question. But it should be held to those responsible, not the entire team or program. How would you like it I’d a few of your coworkers were the responsible parties and you as part of that team were fired? Doubt you would be so quick to agree or finger point or judge. By the way I am NOT a swimmer and I am appalled at the actions of those who ruined the lives of those hazed, harmed, the program and affecting WKU. I am also honored to be a WKU graduate and proud to know Coach Powell and the fine ladies and gentlemen he mentored and coached during my time there. Thoughts and prayers to all those involved directly or indirectly.

Amanda Redmond Stiberth

Agree!! Just like the Arthur Annderson/Enron scandal. Thousands punished for a handful of people. Unfair!

Deanne Thomas
9 years ago

Really what did the Womens Swim Team do? Why are they being suspended?

Susan Taylor Schuster
9 years ago

Agree – Penn state didn’t do away with football

Jocelyne Humbert O'Kane

Doing away with swim and dive takes away from the wronged. Football would not be cut. Punish the faulted not the program.

swimparent
swimparent
9 years ago

Sounds like something the ‘good’ Dr. Timothy Donley is involved in. Deceit and cowardice

Scott O'Connor
9 years ago

University administrations are running roughshod over individual rights in many areas, all because of enhanced enforcement of exaggerated interpretation of Title IX by the Obama Administration, which began with letters to all universities in 2011 demanding that they stop treating criminal behavior as criminal, but by removing the rights of the accused and suspending their Constitutional rights. It has gotten way out of hand. My old fraternity got kicked off campus for telling dirty jokes at its own party. A Duke senior got expelled and got no diploma 2 weeks before graduating after being accused of a sexual assault that local authorities would not prosecute. There are hundreds of examples.

AvantSwim
AvantSwim
9 years ago
Reply to  Scott O'Connor

Obama’s fault? You’re kidding. Anyone but the perpetrators I guess.

Exswimparent
Exswimparent
9 years ago

Bill Powell knew about everything that was going on in the program, just as he did during his 36 years of coaching at WKU. I know first hand what went on in 1999 when my son was a freshman swimmer at WKU….There was a party house back than. Powell’s assistant head coach at the time, Steve Crocker, would be present at the house during parties… Suspending the program is probably something that had to be done by WKU for Lack of Institutional Control over many, many years, not to mention all the criminal stuff that’s gone on. The NCAA would have likely given the program the death penalty anyway, because it needed it.

Deanne Thomas
9 years ago
Reply to  Exswimparent

I have to write say that first hand knowledge is when you are present, you were not. Since I was there in 1999, I can say I have first hand knowledge and I guess I knew your son since we swam at least one year together. Please don’t put down two amazing coaches because your son didn’t enjoy swimming at WKU. Steve Crocker and Coach Powell are two amazing people, friend, mentors and coaches.

Swimmer10
Swimmer10
9 years ago

Sounds like WKU needed to cut a sports team so they used this as the reasoning to give another swim program the ax.

Alumni94
Alumni94
9 years ago

Let me clear it up for everyone. I have first and second hand knowledge of the culture on wku swim team. I not only lived it I helped create it and I’m not ashamed to admit it. Unless you have been a member of a men’s athletic team you have no idea how things really are. Hell yes people are “hazed” not just the freshmen everyone…but at the end of the day we are not only team mates but very good friends. The wku swim team alumni is one the closest group of people you will ever come across. Bottom line is unless you have actually lived it for yourself don’t comment because you don’t really know.
For the record coach Powell is a very good guy. The university named the damn pool after him. Good luck finding anyone who ever met him to say anything bad.

Kate
Kate
9 years ago
Reply to  Alumni94

Well, I was on an athletic team and so was my husband. If you helped create the present culture there and are not ashamed of it, you need some serious help. Please don’t tell people who were not in athletics that they don’t have the right to comment. Wrong is wrong any way you cut it.

AvantSwim
AvantSwim
9 years ago
Reply to  Kate

Agreed!

Deanne Thomas
9 years ago

I wanted everyone to see this amazing story that was in the paper on Sunday before this blew up: http://www.bgdailynews.com/opinion/our_opinion/wku-swimmer-on-right-track/article_e0325cec-cb3a-5a02-b22f-ab4349519e8f.html#.VS2u1YHrcLU- this swimmer is one of the many innocent swimmers in this completely blown up situation. I just wanted to show the amazing side of at least one of the current swimmers.

I have read all of the comments here and wanted to respond but had to get my head around everything. Background story is that I am an alumni swimmer from Western, I swam from 99-03.

– The police have been investigating this situation since the beginning of January and the only charges are of marijuana possession to one student athlete. No allegations or charges have been filed for sexual misconduct or assault and no one has come forth to press charges. One person has said something happened and when the alleged victim was confronted they wanted no charges pressed and didn’t believe that anything happened. Though people have been questioned about the alleged sexual harassment and assault there hasn’t been any evidence to support it or confirmation that it even ever occurred.

– About passed out drunk pictures. My response is really? this isn’t new or anything surprising. Not that people are proud to admit that they have had their drunken moments in College, most of us have had our moments. If you believe that College students are staid and sober and don’t do anything stupid with their friends you live in a hovel with your ears plugged and you eyes glued shut. I am sure these students are embarrassed that pictures where taken but they weren’t spread through mass media- they were posted on a bulletin board in a private house.

– About the Title IX investigation. This was led by a woman who is a right wing conservative who doesn’t believe in the consumption of alcohol. (This is 3rd party knowledge). I know someone that knows her and this is what he said about her. Also he said once she was put in charge the team didn’t have a prayer.

– The President of the University is all about money. He has successfully gotten rid of the mens soccer and tennis program in the last 10 years. He has put the mens swimming up and has been blocked because of alumni support of the program and because of the teams academic success and success in the pool. He built an enormous building and named it after himself, talk about a man with an ego and a man all about money.

– About the coaches. What did the coaches know? That swimmers drink and that recruits are offered alcohol? Or did they know that people bullied other swimmers? I would hope that the coaches would of stepped in and put a stop to bad behavior. If not then punish the coaches and the students responsible. I do not believe that hazing occurred- bullied yes. No evidence has been brought forth that swimmers had to perform certain things to belong (aka hazing). This again is one allegation from one person. About underage drinking and recruits drinking. I want to say again about the wake up and open your eyes. No NCAA athletic program would be around if they cut a program because of this. If you are an athlete or have ever been one you will know this.

– About the distinction of the swimmers. 34 of the 50 are academic all-Americans. They swam great and performed great in the class room. Can this be said for the other sporting programs? If you are going to go into peoples homes and take their computers, pictures, cameras and other personal items what do you think you are going to find? I would ask the University to do just that. If you want to raise the standards of the University put everyone up on the chopping block- fraternities and other sporting programs. Go into student housing ,that the University owns, and see what you find. I promise you will find drunk passed out, half naked, people writing on someone that has passed out pictures. These things should teach people to drink in moderation and don’t drink to the point of falling over. Not that College and Universities should be proud of this and that our culture shouldn’t change but its the truth and not the rare occurrence.

– I am honored to say that I swam and graduated from Western Kentucky University. Coach Powell and Steve Crocker where amazing coaches that taught life lessons and how to be a better person and friend to others.

June
June
9 years ago
Reply to  Deanne Thomas

Bill Powell is a coward. If he was such a good guy he would be standing up for this student athlete, not ignoring his concerns. Clearly things were happening.

Deanne Thomas
9 years ago
Reply to  June

Bill Powell hasn’t been coaching for 10 years. Please don’t call him a coward. He has absolutely nothing to do with the team but go to swim meets and cheer them on. If you want to call a coach out that would be Bruce.

June
June
9 years ago
Reply to  June

Deanne let’s not sit here and act like Bill did not know what was going on. He is a legend there. He had been working with the team up until January 2014. He knows what is going on in his own damn building named after him.

WKU Alum
WKU Alum
9 years ago
Reply to  June

Yo Alex,
Why are you posting under multiple pseudonyms? Quit trolling.

Alumni94
Alumni94
9 years ago

Why would I be ashamed of this culture? Do you know anything about where I should ashamed? Literally over a 1000 men and women have been part of the wku swim team and I have never heard a peep out anyone about the culture and such of the swim team there. One kid out of over a thousand makes allegations and entire program goes down. If things were terrible there why were there no complaints before? If hazing was so out of control why had nobody ever been heard from ? Hazing happens all the time everywhere or what some people want to call hazing. Obviously there is a line that should never be crossed. I just don’t see where the line was crossed or even close to it. Excessive drinking in college? Wow that’s hard to believe…if the kid didn’t want to drink why was he even at the party ?…

Tim
Tim
9 years ago
Reply to  Alumni94

I think clearly everyone here doesn’t understand what the word hazing means. Hazing is defined as “the practice of rituals and other activities involving harassment abuse or humiliation used as a way of initiating a person into a group.” Yes other sports do it. So guess what! Report them then things can be done. But to say oh others do it so la de da is sad and immoral. These are damn kids and it’s about time someone stands up and says this is wrong. The whole “this is what it’s like” is done. These kids get scholarships and get free money to go to wku and they get a lot of added benefits most students don’t get. They get to swim in a damn pool and have fun while everyone else works their ass off studying (not saying they don’t study). They hazed and got what they deserve and for mr Powell to say he doesn’t understand why the kid didn’t go to a coach shows that he thinks that this stuff is no big deal. I can only imagine a real legit situation that would make me Powell concerned.

Alumni94
Alumni94
9 years ago
Reply to  Tim

Powell isn’t the coach!! Obviously some of the current swimmers crossed the line …but the death penalty is way out of bounds here. Fire the coach suspend few of the swimmers who were the problem and move on. If the same problems keep occurring then eventually the death penalty would be called for. Also most the student athletes on wku swim team are not on full scholarship. I’d say very few are. Get to swim in a pool and have fun…please tell me your kidding? There isn’t anything fun about training for swimming. To be honest it’s insane. I graduated 20 years ago and haven’t swam a lap since and never will.

Former Hilltopper
Former Hilltopper
9 years ago
Reply to  Tim

Tim, I get the sense you have never been around collegiate swimming if you think it’s all fun + games + free money- you’re severely mistaken. I sat through classes with “normal” students complaining they had to wake up for a 9 am class and wondering how they would get their homework done before their big party that night when I had been awake since 5:30 for practice and had another one to go. Yes, we as student athletes may get some extra benefits, but we put in the work for them and work our butts off. Same mentality my aunt had- used to think I just showed up at the pool a few times a week and splashed around and used to make extremely snide comments about how lucky I was to have a scholarship. That stopped when she heard my class + practice schedule.
Besides the point, got off on a bit of a tangent there. I’m not saying hazing in any shape or form is ok, but 90% of the things in there are par for the course in college. Freshmen cleaning up after a party? Yes, you live in the dorms and just trashed someone’s home. It’s only fair. I agree that some students got completely out of hand and should be punished, along with the coaching staff who turned a blind eye. I’m not sure if the victim went to the coaching staff or not, but there clearly should have been more support there. But I can say as a former WKU (women’s) swimmer I never saw things there like this is reporting. I believe a few got completely out of hand in the past few years and should be punished. Not completely ruin the future of the program.

Will Tullock
Will Tullock
9 years ago

It is frustrating to see so many posts from people who feel that they have total knowledge of a situation after reading a few articles and a police document. Alas, I shouldn’t expect much more from a magazine comment section where people hide behind anonymous handles.

The reality is there aren’t many people who know the truth about whatever went on with this particular swimmer than the swimmer himself. I don’t know the truth, and I’m not even going to pretend that I know much about it other than what I have heard from a current team member and what I have read. I’m sure that there was some inappropriate behavior going on, and I don’t doubt that he experienced some things that cannot be justified. I also believe that punishment is warranted based on the allegations that I’ve heard. However, I wasn’t there, and it is not my place to make any judgement. It is certainly not my place to trivialize anything the victim had to deal with. The problem is we haven’t let due process run its course, and instead we have tried and found this entire team guilty based on the court of popular opinion.

The place I do feel justified to make judgement is in the response by the university. It is easy for administrators to make the choice to suspend the program for five years. From their perspective, they spend less money, the response looks decisive and their problem goes away. However, I feel that response reeks of poor leadership and it is simply a cop-out. While they do eradicate the problem, they also irreversibly damage the reputation of anyone who is even associated with this swimming program, regardless of whether the team members were guilty of anything or not.

If this was such a systematic problem that had been going on for decades as some on here have said, then why lay a blanket punishment upon 18-22 year olds who are active members of the program for only four years? Why punish High School seniors who were supposed to sign today? Why punish a girl’s team that was not even involved in the allegations? If this is a systematic issue of culture, then the leadership staff of the team and the broader athletic department shoulders the guilt here. An Athletic Director is responsible for the going-ons within his department. The thought that this was going on under his watch and he had NO idea is not acceptable, and it is even more egregious that the culture in his department was so bad that the victim did not feel like there was ANYONE even within the Athletic Department who he could talk to. He had to go to the police.

This happened under him, but Mr. Stewart’s response is to place the blame on the 18-22 year old student athletes instead of sharing the burden of guilt with the coaching staff. Instead of working to find a way to rehabilitate and restore a program, he decides to completely ax it (if you think WKU is actually going to bring back the program in 5 years, get real.) That is poor leadership. Great leaders take responsibility for their actions AND their omissions.

I just wonder if this would have been the response for the football team?

35
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x