FINA World Open Water Championships: Russia Revisited, Hackett Disqualification Report -- May 4, 2008

By Steven Munatones, Swimming World Special Correspondent

SEVILLE, Spain, May 4. SIMILAR to the women's 10K championship yesterday, a British Olympic pool swimmer led the entire way until a savvy Russian surged at the end to claim the gold at the 2008 FINA World Open Water Championships. David Davies dragged the entire lead pack of over 40 men around four loops of the 10K course in Seville. Swimming consistently at 41-43 strokes per minutes, Davies lifted up his head every 20-50 strokes as he led the field.

During the first few loops, Grant Hackett of Australia, Thomas Lurz of Germany and Valerio Cleri of Italy were frequently in and out of the second group on Davies' feet. But immediately following the trio of Hackett, Lurz and Cleri, there was a massive unmovable mass of swimmers representing every continent. Whether it was the front half or back half of each loop in the still-water course, the mass was surging and battling on every stroke, around every turn buoy and at each feeding station.

Throughout the first three loops, Chip Peterson of North Carolina was in the third 4-wide (i.e., four athletes swimming together shoulder-to-shoulder) only a body or two from the leaders, drafting in their wake. Mark Warkentin of Santa Barbara was patient and feeding well, bouncing between either the fourth or fifth 6-wide behind the leaders. With a lead pack of 40+ swimmers giving it their all and Olympic berths on the line, both Chip and Mark were well-positioned.

On the back half of the last loop, Davies took off and took Dyatchin and Lurz with him. The lead pack was now stretched out and shedding swimmers off the back end. Spaniards, Dutch, Italians, Australians and at least swimmers from 12 other countries were all fighting for position and trying not to be lopped off the back end of the pack.

"I got worried on the back half. I did not want to lose contact (with the swimmers ahead of him) and I thought I wouldn't be able to catch up," said Warkentin. It was a tight pack and as we went around the last turn buoy, everyone was climbing on top of one another. I was a bit behind the group ahead of me, but after the last turn, I somehow managed to catch up. Once I caught the next group, I took a couple of deep breaths. I needed to exhale and relax my chest muscles. But, I was still behind the group ahead of me and I didn't think I could shoot the gap. But, then they opened up and I had just enough room to sneak in. Once I got to the guy's feet ahead of me, I focused on his ankles. Then, I focused on his hips. A split second later, I felt a wave (and caught him). It was incredible. It was like I was swimming downstream. The touch pads came up so fast on me."

Warkentin finished in seventh, ensuring a guaranteed spot in the Olympic 10K Marathon Swim finals on August 21st in Beijing. Chip Peterson, the 2005 world 10K champion, finished 13th and will not be going to Beijing. Due to the FINA qualification rules, Luis Escobar of Mexico, who finished 14th 51 seconds behind Peterson, will represent the Americas continent.

As 14 spots were awarded to the athletes in Seville, the battle for gold was a typically classic open water race.

Just before the last buoy, Dyatchin pulled ahead of Davies who had led the group for over an hour and 45 minutes at that point. Coming down the stretch, the men swam stroke-for-stroke. Within 25 meters of the finish, Dyatchin and Davies were smashing into each other on nearly every stroke. Davies swam at a close angle and Dyatchin caught Davies with an elbow on Davies' chin. Davies flinched upwards in pain and looked up at the touch pads, just enough for Dyatchin to get a quarter stroke ahead of Davies and out-touched him for a close victory.

"I really didn't know who was around me. I was just swimming the best way I know how. I don't like people on my shoulders and went to the front," said Davies. "(Dyatchin) is the best swimmer on the (pro open water) circuit and he knows what he is doing. I need to learn how to around the buoys and I don't know what lines to take out of the buoys."

So now a majority of the men's field is set for Beijing. Very importantly, the field will be smaller which has important implications for the tactics and pacing of the Olympic 10K.

"I am not rested or tapered, but I will be fully tapered and shaved for Beijing," recalled Davies, the 2004 1500 bronze medalist. "I'm the first one to admit that I made mistakes (here) which is very encouraging for Beijing."

Davies is a bridge between world class pool and open water swimming, not only in his outlook, but also in his training. "It's nice to do both (the 1500 and 10K). It's a nice mixture. I am fit enough to do both and I'll train for both. I'll do a bit more (open water) racing and gain (more) experience in the 10K before Beijing. A year ago, I wasn't even thinking about doing the 10K. But this swim was very encouraging."

Vladimir Dyatchin (Russia): 1 hour 53 minutes 21.0 seconds – qualified for Beijing
David Davies (Great Britain): 1:53:21.3 (0.3 seconds behind winner) – qualified for Beijing
Thomas Lurz (Germany): 1:53:27.2 (6.2 seconds behind) – qualified for Beijing
Maarten van der Weijden (Netherlands): 1:53:36.2 (15.3 seconds behind) – qualified for Beijing
Evgeny Drattsev (Russia): 1:53:37.6 (16.6 seconds behind) – qualified for Beijing
Ky Hurst (Australia): 1:53:37.6 (16.6 seconds behind) – qualified for Beijing
Mark Warkentin (USA): 1:53:37.8 (16.8 seconds behind) – qualified for Beijing
Valerio Cleri (Italy): 1:53:38.8 (17.8 seconds behind) – qualified for Beijing
Gianniotis Spyridon (Greece): 1:53:39.1 (18.1 seconds behind) – qualified for Beijing
Brian Ryckeman (Belgium): 1:53:39.4 (18.4 seconds behind) – qualified for Beijing
Gilles Rondy (France): 1:53:39.4 (18.4 seconds behind) – qualified for Beijing as European continental representative
Diego Nogueira (Spain): 1:53:41.1 (20.1 seconds behind)
Chip Peterson (USA): 1:53:41.6 (20.6 seconds behind)
Luis Escobar (Mexico): 1:54.32.0 (1:11.0 behind) – qualified for Beijing as Americas continental representative
Ivan Lopez (Mexico): 1:54.32.2 (1:11.2 behind)
Damian Blaum (Argentina): 1:54.34.3 (1:13.3 behind)
Jakub Fichtl (Czech Republic): 1:54.35.1 (1:14.1 behind)
Petar Stoychev (Bulgaria): 1:54:35.7 (1:14.7 behind)
Mohamed El-Zanaty (Egypt): 1:54:36.4 (1:15.4 behind) - qualified for Beijing as African continental representative.
Christian Hein (Germany): 1:54:36.9 (1:15.9 behind)
Alan Bircher (Great Britain): 1:54.44.2 (1:23.2 behind)
Rostislav Vitek (Czech Republic): 1:54:44.7 (1:23.7 behind)
Saleh Mohammed (Syria): 1:54:45.5 (1:24.5 behind) – qualified for Beijing as Asian continental representative
Erwin Maldonado (Venezuela): 1:54:45.8 (1:24.8 behind)
Rolando Salas (Venezuela): 1:54:46.0 (1:25.0 behind)
Michael Dmitriev (Israel): 1:54:48.4 (1:27.4 behind)
Mazen Aziz (Egypt): 1:54:57.4 (1:36.4 behind)
Philippe Dubreuil (Canada): 1:54:59.4 (1:38.4 behind)
Csaba Gercsak (Hungary): 1:54:59.7 (1:38.7 behind)
Jarrod Ballem (Canada): 1:55:04.4 (1:43.4 behind)
Igor Chervynskiy (Ukraine): 1:55:13.4 (1:52.4 behind)
Li Jun Zu (China): 1:55:22.4 (2:01.4 behind)
Simone Ercoli (Italy): 1:55:37.3 (2:16.3 behind)
Bertrand Venturi (France): 1:56:37.6 (3:16.6 behind)
Chad Ho (South Africa): 1:56:50.1 (3:29.1 behind)
Allan Do Carmo (Brazil): 1:56:53.2 (3:32.2 behind)
Alex Schelvis (Netherlands): 1:57:08.8 (3:47.8 behind)
Igor Snitko (Ukraine): 1:57.42.8 (4:21.8 behind)
Roberto Andre Penailillo (Chile): 1:58:16.9 (4:55.9 behind)
Yinhan Li (China): 1:58:30.6 (5:09.6 behind)
Daniel Katzir (Israel): 1:59:04.5 (5:43.5 behind)
Dzmitry Koptur (Belarus): 1:59.10.7 (5:49.7 behind)
Martin Andres Clement (Argentina): 1:59:15.2 (5:54.2 behind)
Marcelo Romanelli Soares (Brazil): 1:59:45.1 (6:24.1 behind)
Aljaz Ojstersek (Slovakia): 2:04:38.1 (11:17.1 behind)
Evgenij Pop Acev (Macedonia): 2:08:01.7 (14:40.7 behind)
Tihomir Ivanchev (Bulgaria): 2:09:49.1 (16:28.1 behind)
Tin Tu Ling (Hong Kong): 2:10:22.2 (17:01.2 behind)
Tomislav Soldo (Croatia) – DNF
Fouad Shkh Bakri (Syria) – DNF
Daniel Viegas (Portugal) – DNF
Christian Bayo (Puerto Rico) – DNF
Grant Hackett (Australia) – DSQ
Jose Francisco Hervas (Spain) – DSQ
Sung Mo Cho (Korean) – DNS

* DNF = did not finish
DSQ = disqualified
DNS = did not start

10K Disqualifications

With so much on the line and so many men swimming aggressively, there were two disqualifications in the 10K race at the 2008 World Open Water Championships.

Jose Francisco Hervas of Spain was red-carded when he clearly pulled back another swimmer within 10 meters of the finish. According to FINA Open Water Swimming Rule 6.3.2, Hervas committed an infraction that was deemed "unsporting" in the opinion of the Referee. With four referees on the course in escort boats positioned on either side of the swimmers, the infraction was not appealed and accepted by the Spanish team.

Fortunately, the infraction did not impact the Olympic selection of the athletes because several Europeans finished ahead of Hervas with the European continental representative selection going to a French swimmer.

However, it was the disqualification of Olympic double gold medalist in the 1500 that drew grasps from the crowd when it was announced. Hackett was disqualified because he committed two separate infractions of the FINA open water swimming rules.

One hour and 24 minutes into the race when there were still 45 men swimming over one another in the lead pack, Hackett was given a yellow card for impeding the progress of another swimmer during the third loop. Officially, he committed an infraction of FINA Rule 6.3.1 for interfering with another swimmer. After the infraction, a card bearing Hackett's number of 35 was written by the Head Referee on a white paper and shown to the swimmers as an indication of a rule violation.

The second infraction was committed with less than 250 meters from the finish in the mad dash to the finish.

When the pace picked up with less than 1000 meters to go, Hackett was caught in the middle of the surging pack. With every stroke, unintentional collisions were made due to the close proximity of the swimmers to each other. As Hackett tried to create more space between himself and the swimmer alongside him, he apparently slowed down and tried deliberately to go over the back of Chip Peterson's legs. Apparently, the degree of separation between Hackett and Peterson was not enough. Unfortunately for both swimmers, Hackett swam over Peterson in a manner that three referees believed impeded the progress of Peterson.

With the second violation, a red flag was raised and Hackett's goal for competing in the Olympic 10K Marathon Swim was over.

"It is unfortunate that any swimmer is disqualified, but in my opinion, the Referee gave the correct decision," explained Sid Cassidy, the chairman of the FINA Technical Open Water Swimming Committee. "The call was confirmed by both Assistant Referees who were also in very close proximity to the infraction. All the referees are experienced international referees."

The disqualification was protested by the Australian team, but the protest was rejected and the official results were issued.

Fortunately, the disqualification did not directly affect the athletes who earned the available spots in Beijing. Ky Hurst who tied for fifth was ahead of both Hackett and Peterson at the time of the infraction and it was clear that Hurst was going to finish in the top ten. With Hurst's top ten finish, Hackett had to finish in the top ten to earn a 10K spot in Beijing. Hackett also cannot enter the second qualifying race in Beijing on June 1 for the same reason (i.e., Hurst getting into the top 10 in Seville). It was estimated that Hackett was in 15th position at the time.

Peterson, who had similarly been knocked around by other competitors throughout the race, ultimately finished in 12th, only 2.2 seconds from a coveted Olympic selection.

Being the gentlemen that he is, Hackett told the Sydney Morning Herald that "I just did not have it in the legs in the end and the decision not to compromise my pool program was a risk you take and in the end I was only two body lengths off the top ten. That is how close it is. But I am going to hold my head up and move on and get back and prepare for the pool program."

Reaction Time Comments

May 4, 2008 Congratulations to Mark!! Sounds like he swam another awesome race! Do you know what happened to Grant Hackett - how did he disqualify? Again, terrific coverage! Thanks.

Submitted by: swimmomof2
May 4, 2008 hackett dq'd! any news on why??
Submitted by: medina
May 4, 2008 We just posted an update on the two disqualifications. Steve is doing an amazing job for us over in Seville!
Submitted by: Jason Marsteller
May 4, 2008 Given that Hackett's disqualification affected Chip Peterson's progress so close to the end, is there any opportunity for him to qualify in the test event? Have the US looked into that??
Submitted by: teamwiess
May 4, 2008 doesn't the person fouled (Peterson) get any consideration in this free for all?
Submitted by: swimsmart
May 4, 2008 I could be completely wrong on this, and I will double-check with Steven about it. But, my understanding of qualifying is that top 10 at Worlds in the 10K is like an A cut in the pool. The only way a country gets two swimmers into an event is if both swimmers clear the A cut.

Otherwise, I believe the test event and other qualifying standards are like the B cut. If you already have someone from your country with an A cut, you can't get in on a B cut.

I'll ask Steven to check into it though.
Submitted by: Jason Marsteller
May 4, 2008 Thanks for that explanation Jason. I think you are right, my comment has to do with the fact that there was a good possibility Peterson would have been top ten without the interference from Hackett. I'm just wondering if because of the infraction, there might be another avenue for chip to get in. It would have to be a special case.
Submitted by: teamwiess
May 4, 2008 Mohamed El Zanaty from Egypt should be qualified to represent the African Continent but Hacket DSQ is just sad to hear !! Incredible race from Davis !!
Submitted by: Hussein91
May 4, 2008 In response to the first comment, Mark Warkentin swam an extremely smart race against the toughest field ever in an men's open water race. Both Mark and his coaches did a wonderful job preparing for this do-or-die race. But, no one really knew the outcome of the race until over 20 minutes after the race was over. The tension on Mark's face during those 20 minutes was very evident.
Submitted by: Munatones
May 4, 2008 In response to teamwiess and swimsmart's questions, the simple answer is no. In fact, throughout the race, everyone with the sole exception of David Davies who was out in front the entire race was battered around the turns, in and out of the feeding station and up and down the 8 legs of the course. Any one collision is much less than the cumulative effect of bumps throughout the entire race. In fact, it was said by some that Hackett was targeted by some of his competitors and was repeatedly bumped and hit throughout the race. Unfortunately, it was near the end when Hackett apparently swam over Chip. But, it would be too difficult for any referee to determine suitable compensation for such an action on the victim (e.g., 1 second, 2 seconds, 3 seconds, 1 meter, 3 meters or 5 meters?). Therefore, in the sport of open water swimming, it truly does "come down to the end". This is why positioning and drafting throughout the race are critical skills for elite swimmers to master. For the recent past, the open water swimming world has marveled at the ability of the top Russians to secure positions in the #2 slot, drafting off the leaders, and then sprint to the finish at the end of the race. This ability is much easier said than done, especially at this level.
Submitted by: Munatones
May 4, 2008 Yes, Mohamed El Zanaty from Egypt did qualify for the Beijing Olympics as the African continental representative. During the third leg, Mohamed moved briefly in the top 5, but the last loop was too much for him to keep a top ten position. That being said, Mohamed finished ahead of swimmers such as Christian Hein and Alan Bircher, so he represented his country well.
Submitted by: Munatones
May 4, 2008 In response to teamwiess, there are 11 remaining spots to fill in the men's 10K at the second qualifying swim in Beijing on June 1st. One of these spots will be alloted to the Chinese representative. The remaining 10 spots will be given to the first 10 finishers with the proviso that each country only gets one spot. However, because Mark Warkentin placed in the top 10, the U.S. does not get one spot. In the same way, countries like Australia, Netherlands, Italy, Greece and Belgium also do not have the opportunity to qualify a second teammate at the Beijing race (because they placed a swimmer in the top ten in Seville). The only country on the men's side that has 2 swimmers in the Olympic 10K final is Russia. In the same way, the only two countries on the women's side that have 2 swimmers in the women's 10K final are Great Britain and Brazil. Therefore, on the men's side, there will be 24 countries represented in the field of 25 male swimmers and 23 countries represented in the field of 25 female swimmers.
Submitted by: Munatones
Reaction Time responses do not necessarily reflect the views or opinions of Swimming World Magazine or
Reaction Time is provided as a service to our readers.

Vladimir Dyatchin beats David Davies at World Open Water Championships
Photo By: Javier Blazquez

Men's 10K finish
Photo By: Javier Blazquez

Turn at Open Water Worlds
Photo By: Javier Blazquez

Men's 10K start
Photo By: Javier Blazquez

Feeding Station
Photo By: Javier Blazquez

Country codes written on head
Photo By: Javier Blazquez

Ky Hurst (kneeling), Thomas Lurz (standing) at World Open Water Championships
Photo By: Javier Blazquez

Subscribe Now!
Subscribe to Swimming World Magazine