Australia and USA Renewing 400 Free Rivalries At Pan Pacs (Medal Predictions)

Photo by Peter H. Bick

Editorial coverage for the Pan Pacific Championships is proudly sponsored by Master Spas!

Each day through August 19 (US), Swimming World will provide medal predictions for the Pan Pacific championships. We invite you to offer your thoughts on who is in line to win medals in the comments section!

Commentary by David Rieder

CHARLESTON, South Carolina, August 15. WITHOUT a doubt, the numbers indicate that the Australian men should be favored in the Pan Pacific 400 free relay. James Magnussen and Cameron McEvoy are the only two men to have swum under 48 seconds headed into the year, and they have a solid third swimmer in Tomasso D’Orsogna, who has clocked a 48.72. However, they have no other men under 49, and Kenneth To, the fourth-place finisher in the event at Australia’s Nationals in April, announced this week he would miss Pan Pacs with a back injury.

The Americans are coming off a decidedly-slow 100 free final at Nationals, but they have options. Nathan Adrian should go head-to-head with Magnussen in the 100 free final, so consider that leg a draw. Unlike Australia, which has clear distinctions between their second, third, and fourth options, the U.S. has a jumbled mess of depth. Jimmy Feigen won the silver medal at the event at Worlds last year, so he probably brings the most potential, though he has not shown he can return to the 47.8-range of last summer.

Michael Phelps and Anthony Ervin both swam 48.7s in prelims at Nationals before slower finals swims, but their swims from later in the week indicate both have better performances in them. Ryan Lochte has become a fixture on this relay, and Matt Grevers is also an option. Although the top four at Nationals were Adrian, Lochte, Feigen, and Conor Dwyer, in that order, National team coordinator Frank Busch indicated that in no way would that dictate the final squad. He said the coaches intend to pick the team based on who is swimming well.

Japan and Canada aren’t known for their freestyle sprinters, so look for Brazil to claim bronze. Even without Cesar Cielo on the team, the likes of Marcelo Cherighini, Bruno Fratus, Nicolas Oliveira, and Joao de Lucca should be able to propel this team to a comfortable third-place finish.

Men’s 400 free relay medal predictions:
United States
Silver: Australia
Bronze: Brazil

Much has changed in the previous year since Megan Romano chased down Alicia Coutts for the U.S. to win the world title in the women’s 400 free relay. First and foremost, neither will likely swim the relay at Pan Pacs. Romano cannot, having not qualified for the U.S. team, while Coutts deals with increased competition from countrywomen as she focused on other events. Without her, the team of Bronte Campbell, Melanie Schlanger, Emma McKeon, and Cate Campbell set the world record in the event with a 3:30.98 at the Commonwealth Games in Glasgow.

That time beat the Americans’ World title-winning time of 3:32.31 by nearly a second and a half. Neither Romano nor Natalie Coughlin will return from that relay, as their spots have been taken by Simone Manuel and Abbey Weitzeil. Manuel came into her own at Nationals, dropping her best time to a 53.60, while Weitzeil emerged as a national contender in the 100 free for the first time. Shannon Vreeland and Missy Franklin will return from that title team, and their veteran presence will be important in guiding the two newcomers.

Unlike the men, the U.S. women won’t have many options to choose from, so even though Weitzeil will likely be the weakest leg, they must ride her out in her first big international meet. In theory, Katie Ledecky could be an option, but her 100 free has not developed to the point where she would be trusted over Weitzeil on this relay.

Meanwhile, Canada should be in the driver’s seat for third for this relay. They finished third behind Australia and England at the Commonwealth Games, and they took fifth at last year’s World Championships – almost two and a half seconds ahead of Japan. The team of Victoria Poon, Sandrine Mainville, Chantal van Landeghem, and Sam Cheverton should all return from that Barcelona squad.

Women’s 400 free relay medal predictions:
Silver: United States
Bronze: Canada

Previous Pan Pacs medal predictions:

400 and 800 freestyle

100 and 200 butterfly

200 and 400 individual medley

100 and 200 backstroke

1 Comment

1 comment

  1. avatar

    Realistically the W 4X100 on an intl basis is AUS v USA then dial for pizza delivery waiting for the rest. ENG’s (in essence the GBR quartet) time at CG would have won them bronze at last year’s Worlds despite finishing 5sec behind AUS. My view is that AUS would been to be some way off Glasgow form …. and US to swim correspondingly well for US to get the upper hand in this one.

    Will have to favour US in the men’s, simply on the grounds of track record. It may not be a particularly fast swim going on recent swims from both camps. It may be a case of who has the least poor legs. Magnussen’s variable relay record is well know; McEvoy threw in a shocker in the 4×200 in Glasgow …… and D’Orsogna has really never been good enough.

Author: David Rieder

David Rieder is the host of Swimming World TV and a staff writer for Swimming World. A contributor to the magazine and website since 2009, he has covered the NCAA Championships, U.S. Nationals, Olympic Trials as well as the 2016 Olympic Games in Rio and the 2017 World Championships in Budapest. He is a native of Charleston, S.C., and a 2016 graduate of Duke University.

Current Swimming World Issue

Trouble Viewing on Smart Phones, Tablets or iPads? Click Here